Results 16-17
| H/A | DATE | OPPOSITION | SCORE | ATT | COMPETITION | VENUE | SPS GOALSCORERS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 13/8/16 | Market Drayton Town | 1-3 | 95 | NPL South Division | Greenfields Sports Ground | Lumsden |
| H | 16/8/16 | Gresley | 1-2 | 117 | NPL South Division | Bracken Moor Stadium | Ruthven |
| A | 20/8/16 | Handsworth Parramore | 1-4 | 129 | FA Cup Preliminary Round | Sandy Lane | Ruthven |
| A | 27/8/16 | Bedworth United | 2-2 | 147 | NPL South Division | The Oval | Muskwe2 |
| H | 29/8/16 | Sheffield | 2-1 | 237 | NPL South Division | Bracken Moor Stadium | McFayden, Biggins |
| A | 3/9/16 | Newcastle Town | 3-1 | 107 | NPL South Division | Lyme Valley Stadium | Muskwe2, Lumsden |
| A | 10/9/16 | Basford United | 2-3 | 96 | NPL South Division | Greenwich Avenue | OG, Muskwe |
| H | 17/9/16 | Carlton Town | 2-1 | 102 | NPL South Division | Bracken Moor Stadium | Muskwe, Lumsden |
| A | 24/9/16 | Northwich Victoria | 0-3 | 91 | NPL South Division | Wincham Park | |
| H | 27/9/16 | Shaw Lane | 1-0 | 136 | NPL South Division | Bracken Moor Stadium | Lumsden |
| A | 1/10/16 | Romulus | 1-0 | 101 | NPL South Division | The Castle Vale Stadium | Lumsden |
| H | 4/10/16 | North Gawber Colliery | 4-0 | 51 | Sheffield Senior Cup 1st Rnd | Bracken Moor Stadium | Lumsden, Hinchcliffe, Poulton |
| A | 8/10/16 | Clitheroe | 5-0 | 270 | FA Trophy Preliminary Rnd | Shawbridge | Biggins, Ruthven, Lumsden, Crofts, Hinchcliffe |
| H | 15/10/16 | Rugby Town | 0-0 | 142 | NPL South Division | Bracken Moor Stadium | |
| A | 18/10/16 | Witton Albion | 0-0 | 186 | NPL South Division | Wincham Park | |
| A | 22/10/16 | Kidsgrove Athletic | 2-1 | 135 | NPL South Division | Hollinwood Road | Biggins, Lumsden |
| H | 29/10/16 | Lancaster City | 2-1 | 128 | FA Trophy 1st Qual Rnd | Bracken Moor Stadium | Lumsden2 |
| H | 1/11/16 | Leek Town | 1-2 | 97 | NPL South Division | Bracken Moor Stadium | Biggins |
| H | 5/11/16 | AFC Rushden & Diamonds | 2-3 | 163 | NPL South Division | Bracken Moor Stadium | Biggins2, Lumsden |
| H | 8/11/16 | Frickley Athletic | 0-4 | 81 | Sheffield Senior Cup 2nd Rnd | Bracken Moor Stadium | |
| A | 12/11/16 | Kidsgrove Athletic | 5-3 | 165 | FA Trophy 2nd Qual Rnd | Hollinwood Road | Biggins, Crofts, Lumsden, Ruthven |
| H | 15/11/16 | Spennymoor Town | 0-2 | 74 | NPL League Cup 1st Rnd | Bracken Moor Stadium | |
| A | 19/11/16 | Spalding United | 3-2 | 112 | NPL South Division | Sir Halley Stewart Field | Biggins, Hinchcliffe, Lumsden |
| H | 26/11/16 | Stalybridge Celtic | 2-2 | 142 | FA Trophy 3rd Qual Rnd | Bracken Moor Stadium | Ruthven, Biggins |
| H | 3/12/16 | Bashford United | 1-2 | 109 | NPL South Division | Bracken Moor Stadium | Crofts |
| A | 6/12/16 | Stalybridge Celtic | 3-2 | 140 | FA Trophy 3rd Qual Rnd Replay | Bower Fold | Crofts, Reay, Hinchcliffe |
| A | 10/12/16 | Nuneaton Town | 1-3 | 346 | FA Trophy 1st Rnd | Liberty Way Ground | Biggins |
| H | 17/12/16 | Northwich Victoria | 2-1 | 105 | NPL South Division | Bracken Moor Stadium | Biggins2 |
| H | 20/12/16 | Stamford | 4-0 | 83 | NPL South Division | Bracken Moor Stadium | Lumsden3, Reay |
| H | 26/12/16 | Chasetown | 1-1 | 117 | NPL South Division | Bracken Moor Stadium | McFayden |
| A | 30/12/16 | Gresley | 0-1 | 229 | NPL South Division | Moat Ground | |
| H | 7/1/17 | Newcastle Town | 1-0 | 97 | NPL South Division | Bracken Moor Stadium | Meade |
| A | 21/1/17 | Shaw Lane | 0-1 | 205 | NPL South Division | Shaw Lane | |
| A | 4/2/17 | Belper Town | 0-0 | 245 | NPL South Division | Christchurch Meadow | |
| H | 14/2/17 | Romulus | 1-0 | 85 | NPL South Division | Bracken Moor Stadium | Hinchcliffe |
| A | 18/2/17 | Rugby Town | 1-0 | 201 | NPL South Division | Ruthven | |
| H | 25/2/17 | Kidsgrove Athletic | 0-2 | 96 | NPL South Division | Bracken Moor Stadium | |
| H | 28/2/17 | Witton Albion | 3-4 | 111 | NPL South Division | Bracken Moor Stadium | Hinchcliffe2, Biggins |
| A | 7/3/17 | Leek Town | 1-1 | 198 | NPL South Division | Butlin Road | Ruthven |
| H | 11/3/17 | Loughborough Dynamo | 4-2 | 97 | NPL South Division | Bracken Moor Stadium | Ruthven, Litchfield, Stirrup, Biggins |
| A | 14/3/17 | Carlton Town | 0-1 | 71 | NPL South Division | Bill Stokeld Stadium | |
| A | 18/3/17 | Stamford | 5-0 | 252 | NPL South Division | Vic Couzens Stadium | Stirrup, Biggins, Ruthven2, Hobson |
| H | 21/3/17 | Lincoln United | 0-3 | 94 | NPL South Division | Bracken Moor Stadium | |
| A | 25/3/17 | Loughborough Dynamo | 3-2 | 100 | NPL South Division | Nanpantan Sports Ground | Grayson, Lumsden, Litchfield |
| H | 28/3/17 | Belper Town | 2-1 | 117 | NPL South Division | Bracken Moor Stadium | Stirrup2 |
| H | 1/4/17 | Spalding United | 2-0 | 95 | NPL South Division | Bracken Moor Stadium | Reay, Litchfield |
| A | 4/4/17 | Sheffield | 2-1 | 236 | NPL South Division | Coach & Horses Ground | Lumsden, Ruthven |
| A | 8/4/17 | Lincoln United | 2-0 | 201 | NPL South Division | Ashby Avenue | Rhodes, Litchfield |
| A | 11/4/17 | AFC Rushden & Diamonds | 2-0 | 449 | NPL South Division | Hayden Road | Reay, Biggins |
| H | 15/4/17 | Market Drayton Town | 4-1 | 162 | NPL South Division | Bracken Moor Stadium | Ruthven, Lumsden, McFayden, Biggins |
| A | 17/4/17 | Chasetown | 2-1 | 118 | NPL South Division | The Scholars Ground | Biggins2 |
| H | 22/4/17 | Bedworth United | 1-1 | 114 | NPL South Division | Bracken Moor Stadium | Litchfield |
| A | 25/4/17 | Spalding United | 2-31 | 448 | NPL South Division Play Off Semi Final | Sir Halley Stewart Field | Stirrup, Biggins |
1After extra time